Evidence Room home
The skid tracks
What Gord Logan could see
Lynne's hitchhiking
The missing witness
Jocelyne Gaudet
The Kalichuk file
The other men
The June 11th bulletin
Doctored evidence
The lab report

The lab report
Maps
The 1959 headlines
The arrest
The death penalty

The Lab Report

Nobody from the Attorney General's laboratory testified at the trial, but Crown prosecutor Glenn Hays assured the jurors that the experts there endorsed the findings of pathologist John Penistan. Penistan insisted his analysis of the stomach made it a certainty that Lynne was murdered between 7:00 and 7:45 pm.

OPP inspector Harold Graham testified that it was not until he received the laboratory report that Steve "became a strong suspect." The judge later concluded: "I think I can properly infer whatever was in the laboratory report clinched the matter."

What exactly was in the report that "clinched" Steven's guilt?

Hays never entered the crucial laboratory report into evidence. And for good reason. Funk's report was only one page long. It listed in detail what was inside Lynne's stomach. But it said not a word about time of death:

Click to read the laboratory report yourself

The implications are staggering. Imagine if Graham had claimed on the basis of a phone call, he learned the lab had confirmed a suspect's knife was the murder weapon, but then was unable to produce a written lab report to back up that claim. He would be laughed out of court. Yet that is exactly what Hays pulled off with a much-talked about but never seen lab report supposedly confirming time of death.

Read more about the lab report in Chapter 30 of "Until you are Dead".

 

About the Book | Read Excerpt | Reviews | Latest News | Evidence Room
About the Author | Author Tour | Submit a Tip | Links
New Books from Random House | Search Catalogue
© Random House of Canada Limited. All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy